16 Comments
User's avatar
Jay Friedman's avatar

Thank you Jeremy. I view the US under Trump and Israel under Netanyahu through the same lens: in both cases, leaders have hugely broken democratic norms, weakened the rule of law, and treated institutions as obstacles rather than guardrails. This is bad policy with lasting damage to social trust, democratic legitimacy, and each country’s moral standing. At some point, we have to be honest that real change may not be possible while either man remains in power. Renewal will require new leadership willing to restore restraint, accountability, and respect for democracy itself.

Jeremy Ben-Ami's avatar

Absolutely - we desperately need - and have to work to get - change in leadership and direction in both countries. I believe it's existential for American democracy and for the idea of Israel as a country with both a democratic character and a Jewish nature. And when we do get change - we must not focus on 'going back' to what was, we absolutely have to focus on building something better in both countries.

edwin stromberg's avatar

Excellent, thoughtful commentary, as usual. The paragraph that begins "the government's assault on democratic norms..." could easily have been written about--guess what other country's leader-- that it's hard to see the distinction between Israel's direction and this other nation's political direction.

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

Absolutely.And it's so heartening to see the resistance here growing. I hope it's not too late.

Ivor's avatar

It is not only the Israeli government that is not keeping to the laws. The US is also breaking through the guidelines on which laws are based.

Daniel Friedman's avatar

sobering, concerning, and unfortunately accurate analysis

Anastasia Pantsios's avatar

This reflects a lot of what I have been thinking as well. It can be hard to let go for those of us in the post WWII generation raised on collecting dimes at the J to plant trees in the newborn Israel, and learning decades later that many of our classmates came to this country as children with parents who were trying to get as far as possible from the camps they'd survived. Things need to change in this country in a major way as well. We need to call out OUR president for pretending to fight anti-Semitism as a cover for his authoritarianism.

Michael Lewis's avatar

Again, an off-the-cuff response, somewhat meandering response, which should be - but isn't being - "polished" before posting!

I actually do not wish to attempt to refute/rebut or deny the many obvious problems/issues in Israeli society and politics. And the problems in the United States and Europe from the HATERS of Israel.

I think you underestimate the continued and growing threats TO Israel. Especially from Iran. But from many other sources as well. And overestimate Israel's strength.

But even taken J Street at its word that you're all committed to and concerned about Israel's future security and survival - Something some do question given some of the J Street positions you've adopted over the years. And I'd also argue that some of these splits and strains, have in part come about - or at least have been accentuated and worsened BY the activities of J Street. And by your willingness as an organization to support political candidates, in no small part because you support their social issues - and are almost always willing to forgive their not-infrequent hostile-to-Israel positions. That's obviously a legitimate thing to do as an organization. A little less so if your priority as an organization is to advance the US-Israel relationship.

I don't agree with my former organization, AIPAC, on everything it does or says (or doesn't say or do). (Or what officials from the Government of Israel say or do. Or re various things occurring in the United States.) Not when I was there. And not now. But as a general rule; I don't think it's illogical for an organization,seeking to promote the US-Israel relationship should support those candidates who they views as most "pro-Israel" regardless of you regard the candidate's other views. And yes I fully-appreciate the "Side effects." And obviously there can be special exceptions. But there are plenty of other organizations out there, often with same people involved, who can express counter views.

I hate the antipathy that has developed among many Democrats towards Israel and towards AIPAC. And I'm not suggesting either Israel or AIPAC have been blameless. I hate that Anti-Zionism has grown; I hate that many American Jews are not supportive - or even interested in Israel. I grew up in England when almost all Jews were passionately concerned about Israel

Bottom line: I'd like Israel to change some things internally and externally. But I also want American supporters of Israel to support Israel. And of course the ultimate thing I want re Israel - is that it continues to exist as a safe and secure Jewish State. As a sanctuary for Jews.

Now obviously I realize that views can differ over how to achieve that goal. But that should be the goal for anyone and everyone who says they are pro Israel.

And I think the way forward is especially for supporters of Israel is not to weaken the bonds you spoken of and not to heighten the dangers of Israel. Sure speak out and criticize Israel and Israeli actions. (The days of urging US Jews not to publicly criticize Israel are long gone). And of course any non-Israeli supporter of Israel has to recognize and internalize what are the positions held by most Israelis regarding the peace process; Arab threats, etc. Truly is the case that they're ultimately the ones who pay the price. So there's a extra responsibility for those who assume mantle of "Pro-Israel" advocate. It's surely not to give cover to those who are not pro-Israel. (On Left and Right)

There's more I could respond to; but think that's enough!

(*Slightly edited a few words)

Jill's avatar

So where does Hamas and Israel's enemies like Iran fit into this analysis? You seem to think that any strain in the U.S./Israel relationship falls squarely on the shoulders of Bibi and his malignant minions. Yet in the interim of the Israel-Hamas War, U.S. voters put the Orange Man back into power, thus indicating that the pendulum in both countries has swung right (at least for now...though I hope the tide on that will shift in the midterm elections). Have you stopped to consider that the explosion of antisemitism motivating a lot of this behavior against Israel and Jews isn't necessarily on Israel or Jews?

Jeremy Ben-Ami's avatar

That's an easy one, Jill. You usually have tougher questions. It's vital to both US and Israeli interests to defeat extremism - whether in the form of state actors as in Iran or non-state actors as in Hamas, Hezbollah, etc. The Arab states are on board with those goals as well. The problem for the future of the US-Israel relationship is that - rather than focus on cooperative work with its neighbors addressing those threats with a multipronged strategy that includes creating a future for Palestinians - this extremist Israeli government is interested only in full Jewish control from the River to the Sea, with no space for the development over time of a state for the other half of the people who live in that land. That's what causing the rupture - not the existence of Iran or Hamas. The problem is that this extremist Israeli government is pursuing a path that diverges from US interests (and the region's interests) and the values that I believe the majority of Americans (Jewish and not) still hold. I am talking hear about the rupture between Americans and the state of Israel - not about antisemitism.

David Wluka's avatar

An excellent commentary but fatally flawed on several counts. I acknowledge that the politics are inconsistent with democratic values. We have far right governments in both countries using a manufactured crisis in the case of the US and a real one in Israel to gain power. Israel's existential right to exist has yet to be acknowledged. It is Hamas, not Israel, who put Gazans in the situation they are in. It's Hamas, Hezbollah, and the other Iran supported groups wanting to eradicate Israel who are the perpetrators of Genocide. My question to readers here....what would you do?

Sonoma Susie's avatar

I would take the 1995 Oslo Accords and clean up Areas, A, B, and C to be stabilized and functional regarding occupation and administration. Once these areas are functioning well and deradicalized with no terrorist occupiers, then Israelis and Gazans can progress to a Palestinian state. The radicalization of both Gaza and the West Bank and nearby Arab states by extremist Islamists makes instant statehood a fantasy. Recognition of Israel's right to their sovereign state of Israel is a requirement for any who choose to identify themselves as citizens of a Palestinian state. Also I am assuming that the current regime in Iran will failin the near term, and then it will revert back to the Persian Iranians who can live in peace with Israel.

David Wluka's avatar

The concept makes great sense. Your operative statement is;

" Once these areas are functioning well and deradicalized with no terrorist occupiers,"

How do we get there?

Jonathan Farber's avatar

No, it was the October 7 attack by an UNoccupied Gaza that killed the possibility of a Palestinian state. Israelis don't commit genocide, and they're not going to commit suicide either.

Carolyn Herz's avatar

Great essay. Here's a hypothetical: If Israel were to unilaterally withdraw from all occupied territories back to its pre-1967 borders, and recommit to democratic ideals, how would the U.S. respond? I suspect, sadly, that many U.S. government officials, and possibly also some Jews, would reduce their support for Israel.